(Updated July 25, 2022)
All OGP member countries are expected to develop and implement action plans in line with OGP Participation & Co-creation Standards and timelines. A country’s participation in OGP may be reviewed by the Steering Committee if it fails to meet these minimum requirements.
The Procedural Review informs how to address these situations, and helps ensure that all OGP members act in accordance with the OGP process. An OGP member country is considered to have acted contrary to process when any of the following takes place:
- The government does not publish an OGP action plan within 12 months after the end date of their last action plan.
- The government does not meet the minimum requirements established in the Participation & Co-Creation Standards, as assessed by the IRM.
- The government fails to make progress on implementation of any of the commitments in the country’s action plan, as assessed by the IRM.
The Support Unit will notify the government when it has acted contrary to process, and will publish the notification letter in the repository below and in the OGP Gazette.
Countries that act contrary to the OGP process for two consecutive action plan cycles will be automatically placed under “Procedural Review” by the Criteria and Standards (C&S) Subcommittee. This review involves enhanced support by the Support Unit and Steering Committee to help address the issues that have led to the review.
The list of countries under Procedural Review is published below, and updated on a rolling basis. A country’s status will also be noted on other public information materials, where appropriate (e.g., in a list of participating OGP countries and OGP country page).
To be removed from this list, a country must rectify the actions that resulted in being placed under review (i.e. the second instance of acting contrary to process, in two consecutive cycles, and chronologically) in line with the following protocol:
Reason for being placed under Procedural Review |
Requirement to be removed from Procedural Review |
---|---|
Late action plan |
Submit a new action plan by the established deadline |
Not meeting the minimum Participation & Co-Creation Standards |
Meet the minimum requirements during the next moment in the country’s OGP process (co-creation or implementation) as assessed by the IRM. Action Plan Review reports are published within four months after delivery of a new plan. Results Reports are published within four months after completing implementation of the plan. Note: the minimum requirements assessed in each report are different. See the IRM Guidelines for the Assessment of Minimum Requirements for more details. |
Not making progress in implementation of any of the commitments |
Show evidence of making progress on implementation of any of the commitments in the country’s next action plan, as assessed by the IRM in the Results Report published within four months after completing implementation of the plan. Note: the Procedural Review due to this reason could last over two years. |
If a country fails to deliver an action plan for three consecutive years, the C&S Subcommittee will automatically recommend that the country be designated as “inactive” in OGP by resolution of the Steering Committee. The C&S Subcommittee, in consultation with the Support Unit, may also recommend inactivity when a country acts contrary to process on numerous occasions and in different ways.
The terms of inactivity resolutions, and the circumstances in which a country may regain active status, or be required to withdraw from OGP, are determined at the discretion of the Steering Committee, and informed by the Procedural Review protocols above (e.g. if a country is placed in inactive status due to not delivering an action plan for three consecutive years, it must then deliver an action plan by an established deadline).
If a country is placed in inactive status due to other reasons, the Steering Committee will determine the conditions needed to end the inactivity status, also informed by the Procedural Review protocols.
Procedural Review Cases
(Updated May 20, 2024)
The Support Unit will make public all communications regarding governments acting contrary to process below, and list all countries that are currently under review or designated as inactive pursuant to Procedural Review in this page. Any inquiries can be directed to the OGP Support Unit at info@opengovpartnership.org
Countries currently under review:
Official letters sent to OGP Countries are posted here.
2024
- Georgia – Process Update Letter (October 2024)
- United States – Process Update Letter (September 2024)
- Australia – Process Update Letter (September 2024)
- Greece – Participation Status Resolution by C&S Subcommittee (May 2024)
- South Africa – Procedural Review Resolution by C&S Subcommittee (May 2024)
- Liberia – Under Review Letter (April 2023)
- Kyrgyz Republic – Resolution Regarding Participation Status (May 2024)
- North Macedonia – Contrary to Process Letter (May 2024)
- Sri Lanka – Resolution Regarding Participation Status (May 2024)
- Greece – Resolution Regarding Participation Status (April 2024)
- South Africa – Resolution Regarding Participation Status (April 2024)
- Mexico – Under Review Letter – April 2024
- Malta – Status Letter (March 2024)
- Ireland – Contrary to Process Letter (March 2024)
- Jamaica – Contrary to Process Letter (March 2024)
- Kyrgyz Republic – Contrary to Process and Status Letter (March 2024)
- Morocco – Contrary to Process Letter (March 2024)
- Sri Lanka – Contrary to Process and Status Letter – March 2024
- Sierra Leone – Contrary to Process Letter (March 2024)
- South Africa – Contrary to Process and Status Letter (March 2024)
2023
- Israel – Update to Status (August 2023)
- Bulgaria – Process Update Letter (August 2023)
- Armenia – Process Update Letter (August 2023)
- United States – Contrary to Process Letter (August 2023)
- Norway – Contrary to Process Letter (August 2023)
- Denmark – Under Review Letter (August 2023)
- South Africa – Under Review Letter (August 2023)
- Azerbaijan – Withdrawal from Partnership (July 2023)
- Sweden – Contrary to Process Letter (July 2023)
- Papua New Guinea – Eligibility Review Letter (June 2023)
- Senegal – Eligibility Review Letter (June 2023)
- Albania – Procedural Review Resolution by C&S Subcommittee (April 2023)
- Malta – Participation Status Resolution by Steering Committee (April 2023)
- Norway – Procedural Review Resolution by C&S Subcommittee (April 2023)
- Seychelles – Procedural Review Resolution by C&S Subcommittee (April 2023)
- Sri Lanka – Procedural Review Resolution by C&S Subcommittee (April 2023)
- Sweden – Procedural Review Resolution by C&S Subcommittee (April 2023)
- South Africa – Contrary to Process Letter (March 2023)
- Kyrgyz Republic – Under Review Letter (February 2023)
- Sri Lanka – Contrary to Process Letter (February 2023)
- Moldova – Under Review Letter (February 2023)
- Ukraine – Status Letter (February 2023)
- Denmark – Contrary to Process Letter (February 2023)
- Kenya – Contrary to Process Letter (February 2023)
- Nigeria – Contrary to Process Letter (February 2023)
- Philippines – Contrary to Process Letter (February 2023)
- Netherlands – Contrary to Process Letter (February 2023)
- Australia – Under Review Letter (February 2023)
- Israel – Inactivity Letter (February 2023)
- Cabo Verde – Update to OGP Status (February 2023)
- Georgia – Under Review Letter (February 2023)
- Malawi – Update to OGP Status (February 2023)
- Chile – Contrary to Process Letter (February 2023)
- Colombia – Contrary to Process Letter (February 2023)
- Costa Rica – Contrary to Process Letter (February 2023)
- Czech Republic – Contrary to Process Letter (February 2023)
- Honduras – Under Review Letter (February 2023)
- Mexico – Contrary to Process Letter (February 2023)
- Norway – Contrary to Process and Status Letter (February 2023)
- Peru – Contrary to Process Letter (February 2023)
- Serbia – Contrary to Process Letter (February 2023)
- Seychelles – Contrary to Process and Status Letter (February 2023)
- Sweden – Contrary to Process and Status Letter (February 2023)
- Albania – Contrary to Process Letter (January 2023)
2022
- Luxembourg – OGP Response to Letter of Withdrawal (December 2022)
- Luxembourg – Letter of Withdrawal From OGP (December 2022)
- United Kingdom – Procedural Review Resolution by C&S Subcommittee (December 2022)
- United Kingdom – Update on Process [Response to Contrary to Process Letter] (November 2022)
- Burkina Faso – Eligibility Review Letter (September 2022)
- Tunisia – Eligibility Review Letter (September 2022)
- Senegal – Eligibility Review Letter (September 2022)
- Luxembourg – Under Review Letter (September 2022)
- Papua New Guinea – Eligibility Review Letter (September 2022)
- United Kingdom – Response to Contrary to Process Letter (September 2022)
- France – Contrary to Process Letter (August 2022)
- Sierra Leone – Contrary to Process Letter (August 2022)
- United Kingdom – Contrary to Process Letter (August 2022)
- Bulgaria – Letter Regarding Status (July 2022)
- Mongolia – Letter Regarding Status (July 2022)
- Cabo Verde – Contrary to Process Letter (April 2022)
- Seychelles – Under Review Letter (April 2022)
- Republic of Moldova – Response to Contrary to Process Letter (April 2022)
- Israel – Response to Inactivity Recommendation (March 2022)
- Bulgaria – Participation Status Resolution (March 2022)
- El Salvador – Participation Status Resolution (March 2022)
- Israel – Participation Status Resolution (March 2022)
- Malawi – Participation Status Resolution (March 2022)
- Malta – Participation Status Resolution (March 2022)
- Malta – Response to Inactivity Status Recommendation (March 2022)
- Sri Lanka – Contrary to Process Letter (March 2022)
- Dominican Republic – Under Review Letter (March 2022)
- Republic of Moldova – Contrary to Process Letter (March 2022)
- Kyrgyz Republic – Contrary to Process Letter (March 2022)
- El Salvador – Letter Informing of New Ministerial and Government Point of Contact (March 2022)
- Bulgaria – Letter Regarding Inactive Status Recommendation (March 2022)
- Israel – Letter Regarding Inactive Status Recommendation (March 2022)
- Malawi – Letter Regarding Inactive Status Recommendation (March 2022)
- Malta – Letter Regarding Inactive Status Recommendation (March 2022)
- Sierra Leone – Contrary to Process Letter (March 2022)
- Pakistan – Letter Regarding Withdrawal (March 2022)
- El Salvador – Letter Regarding Inactive Status Recommendation (March 2022)
- Israel – Letter Regarding Status (February 2022)
- Cabo Verde – Under Review Letter (February 2022)
- Mongolia – Contrary to Process Letter (February 2022)
- Montenegro – Contrary to Process Letter (February 2022)
- Papua New Guinea – Contrary to Process Letter (February 2022)
- Italy – Contrary to Process Letter (February 2022)
- Jamaica – Letter Regarding Status (February 2022)
- Canada – Contrary to Process Letter (February 2022)
- Armenia – Contrary to Process Letter (February 2022)
- Australia – Contrary to Process Letter (February 2022)
- Bosnia and Herzegovina – Contrary to Process Letter (February 2022)
- Croatia – Contrary to Process Letter (February 2022)
- Georgia – Contrary to Process Letter (February 2022)
- Latvia – Contrary to Process Letter (February 2022)
- Luxembourg – Contrary to Process Letter (February 2022)
- Seychelles – Contrary to Process Letter (February 2022)
- Slovak Republic – Contrary to Process Letter (February 2022)
2021
- Paraguay – Cohort Shift (December 2021)
- Ghana – Letter Regarding Status (October 2021)
- Pakistan – Letter Regarding Status (September 2021)
- Honduras – Notification of Late Action Plan (Cohort Shift) – September 2021
- Albania – Under Review Letter (September 2021)
- Mongolia – Under Review Letter (September 2021)
- New Zealand – Extension and Cohort Shift (August 2021)
- Morocco – Contrary to Process Letter (August 2021)
- Burkina Faso – Under Review Letter (July 2021)
- El Salvador – Contrary to Process Letter (July 2021)
- El Salvador – Under Review Letter (July 2021)
- Papua New Guinea – Eligibility Update Letter (July 2021)
- Tunisia – Under Review Letter (July 2021)
- United States – Response from US Government (April 2021)
- Sweden – Response to Under Review Letter (March 2021)
- United Kingdom – Response to Under Review Letter (March 2021)
- United States – Contrary to Process Letter (March 2021)
- Cabo Verde – Contrary to Process Letter (March 2021)
- Kenya – Contrary to Process Letter (March 2021)
- Greece – Under Review Letter – February 2021
- Sweden – Under Review Letter – February 2021
- Norway – Under Review Letter – February 2021
- United Kingdom – Under Review Letter (February 2021)
2020
- Papua New Guinea – Under Review Letter – August 2020
- Burkina Faso – Letter Regarding Eligibility (August 2020)
- El Salvador – Letter Regarding Eligibility (August 2020)
- Tunisia – Letter Regarding Eligibility (September 2020)
- Papua New Guinea – Letter Regarding Eligibility (August 2020)
- Albania – Letter Acting Contrary to Process (Standards) – July 2020
- Dominican Republic – Letter Acting Contrary to Process (Standards) – July 2020
- Jamaica – Letter from Steering Committee Regarding Resolution – March 2020
- Pakistan – Letter from Steering Committee Regarding Inactivity Resolution – March 2020
- Bulgaria – Under Review Letter – February 2020
- Colombia – Cohort Shift Letter – February 2020
- Ghana – Under Review Letter – February 2020
- Ireland – Under Review Letter – February 2020
- Israel – Under Review Letter – February 2020
- Liberia – Cohort Shift Letter – February 2020
- Malawi – Under Review Letter – February 2020
- Malta – Under Review Letter – February 2020
- Pakistan – Inactivity Letter – February 2020
- Panama – Cohort Shift Letter – February 2020
- Senegal – Cohort Shift Letter – February 2020
- South Africa – Under Review Letter – February 2020
- Spain – Cohort Shift Letter – February 2020
2019
- Trinidad and Tobago – Letter informing the Government of its withdrawal from OGP
- Jamaica – Letter Regarding Potential Inactive Status – November 2019
- Pakistan – Notification of Late Action Plan (Procedural Review) – Updated October 2019
- Papua New Guinea – Letter regarding OGP eligibility – July 2019
- Austin, United States – Notification of Late Action Plan (Cohort Shift) – January 2019
- Bojonegoro, Indonesia – Notification of Late Action Plan (Cohort Shift) – January 2019
- Bulgaria – Notification of Late Action Plan (Cohort Shift) – January 2019
- Greece – Notification of Late Action Plan (Cohort Shift) – January 2019
- Iasi, Romania – Notification of Late Action Plan (Cohort Shift) – January 2019
- Ireland – Notification of Late Action Plan (Cohort Shift) – January 2019
- Italy – Notification of Late Action Plan (Cohort Shift) – January 2019
- Jalisco, Mexico – Notification of Late Action Plan (Cohort Shift) – January 2019
- Kigoma, Tanzania – Notification of Late Action Plan (Cohort Shift) – January 2019
- Malawi – Notification of Late Action Plan (Cohort Shift) – January 2019
- Mongolia – Notification of Late Action Plan (Cohort Shift) – January 2019
- Nariño, Colombia – Notification of Late Action Plan (Cohort Shift) – January 2019
- Norway – Notification of Late Action Plan (Cohort Shift) – January 2019
- Ontario, Canada – Notification of Late Action Plan (Cohort Shift) – January 2019
- Paris, France – Notification of Late Action Plan (Cohort Shift) – January 2019
- Sierra Leone – Notification of Late Action Plan (Cohort Shift) – January 2019
- Sri Lanka – Notification of Late Action Plan (Cohort Shift) – January 2019
- Sweden – Notification of Late Action Plan (Cohort Shift) – January 2019
- United Kingdom – Notification of Late Action Plan (Cohort Shift) – January 2019
- Mexico – Notification of Late Action Plan (Cohort Shift) – January 2019
- South Africa – Notification of Late Action Plan (Cohort Shift) – January 2019
- Jamaica – Notification of Late Action Plan (Procedural Review) – January 2019
- Luxembourg – Notification of Late Action Plan (Procedural Review) – January 2019
- United States – Notification of Late Action Plan (Procedural Review) – January 2019
2018
- Montenegro – End of inactivity status – December 2018
- Bosnia and Herzegovina – Notification of inactivity status – December 2018
- Trinidad and Tobago – Notification of inactivity status – December 2018
- Papua New Guinea – Letter regarding OGP eligibility – June 2018
- Mexico – Update for the SU on 4th Action Plan Process – April 2018
- Thailand – Letter Regarding Eligibility – February 2018
- Albania – 2017 Late SAR Letter – February 2018
- Estonia – 2017 Late SAR Letter – February 2018
- France – 2017 Late SAR Letter – February 2018
- Ireland – 2017 Late SAR Letter – February 2018
- Israel – 2017 Late SAR Letter – February 2018
- Kenya – 2017 Late SAR Letter – February 2018
- Latvia – 2017 Late SAR Letter – February 2018
- Malta – 2017 Late SAR Letter – February 2018
- Mexico – 2017 Late SAR Letter – February 2018
- Moldova – 2017 Late SAR Letter – February 2018
- Mongolia – 2017 Late SAR Letter – February 2018
- South Africa – 2017 Late SAR Letter – February 2018
- Sri Lanka – 2017 Late SAR Letter – February 2018
- Sweden – 2017 Late SAR Letter – February 2018
- Trinidad and Tobago – 2017 Late SAR Letter – February 2018
- United States – 2017 Late SAR Letter – February 2018
- Bosnia and Herzogovina – Cohort Shift Letter – January 2018
- Cabo Verde – Cohort Shift Letter – January 2018
- Croatia – Cohort Shift Letter – January 2018
- France – Cohort Shift Letter – January 2018
- Jamaica – Cohort Shift Letter – January 2018
- Luxembourg – Cohort Shift Letter – January 2018
- Malta – Cohort Shift Letter – January 2018
- Pakistan – Cohort Shift Letter – January 2018
- Papua New Guinea – Cohort Shift Letter – January 2018
- Trinidad and Tobago – Cohort Shift Letter – January 2018
- United States – Cohort Shift Letter – January 2018
2017
- Jamaica – OGP Letter – December 2017
- Peru – OGP Letter – December 2017
- Trinidad and Tobago – OGP Letter – December 2017
- United States – OGP Letter – December 2017
- Afghanistan – OGP Letter – November 2017
- Bosnia and Herzegovina – OGP Letter – November 2017
- Cabo Verde – OGP Letter – November 2017
- Croatia – OGP Letter – November 2017
- Denmark – OGP Letter – November 2017
- France – OGP Letter – November 2017
- Ghana – OGP Letter – November 2017
- Israel – OGP Letter – November 2017
- Latvia – OGP Letter – November 2017
- Luxembourg – OGP Letter – November 2017
- Malta – OGP Letter – November 2017
- Pakistan – OGP Letter – November 2017
- Papua New Guinea – OGP Letter – November 2017
- Montenegro – Notification of Inactivity Status (July 2017)
- Montenegro – Steering Committee Resolution for Inactivity Status (July 2017)
- Tunisia – OGP Letter – July 2017
- Mongolia Late Self – Assessment Report Letter – March 2017
- Mexico Late Self – Assessment Report Letter – March 2017
- Trinidad and Tobago Late Self – Assessment Report Letter – March 2017
- Bulgaria Late Self – Assessment Report Letter – March 2017
- Montenegro – OGP Letter – February 2017
- Bosnia and Herzegovina – OGP Letter – January 2017
- Cabo Verde – OGP Letter – January 2017
- Croatia – OGP Letter – January 2017
- Denmark – OGP Letter – January 2017
- Montenegro – OGP Letter – January 2017
- Papua New Guinea – OGP Letter – January 2017
- Spain – OGP Letter – January 2017
- Tanzania – OGP Letter – January 2017
- Trinidad and Tobago – OGP Letter – January 2017
2016
- Australia – Steven Kennedy – November 2016
- Bosnia and Herzegovina – Late Letter November 2016
- Brazil – Late Letter November 2016 – November 2016
- Cabo Verde – Late Letter – November 2016
- Croatia – Late Letter – November 2016
- Denmark – Late Letter – November 2016
- Ireland – Late Letter – November 2016
- Moldova – Late Letter – November 2016
- Papua New Guinea – Late Letter – November 2016
- Spain – Late Letter – November 2016
- Sweden – Late Letter – November 2016
- Tanzania – Late Letter – November 2016
- Trinidad – Late Letter – November 2016
- Ukraine – Late Letter – November 2016
- Vujica Lazovic – Montenegro – November 2016
- South Korea – OGP Letter – September 2016
- Montenegro – OGP Letter – August 2016
- Greece – OGP Letter – March 2016
- New Zealand – OGP Letter – March 2016
- Trinidad and Tobago – OGP Letter – March 2016
- Tanzania – OGP Letter – March 2016
- Papua New Guinea – OGP Letter – February 2016
2015
- Bosnia – OGP Letter – November 2015
- Kenya – OGP Letter – November 2015
- Malawi – OGP Letter – November 2015
- Montenegro – OGP Letter – November 2015
2014
- South Korea – OGP Letter – April 2014
- Trinidad and Tobago – OGP Letter – April 2014
- Turkey – OGP Letter – April 2014
- Mongolia – OGP Letter – April 2014
- Malta – OGP Letter – April 2014
- Lithuania – OGP Letter – April 2014
- Azerbaijan – OGP Letter – April 2014
- Spain – OGP Letter – April 2014
- Paraguay – OGP Letter – April 2014
- Guatemala – OGP Letter – April 2014
- Dominican Republic – OGP Letter – April 2014